Saturday, July 17, 2010

Kashmiriyat Revisited

This 18th June, Friday (2010), nearly thousands of Kashmiri pandits, including women and children, visited the temple of Mata Kheer Bhavani in Tullamula, 20 Kilometers from Shrinagar. It was the sacred day of Zyeshtha Ashthami. Most of the Pandits were visiting the valley after nearly 20 years, since the time they left Kashmir due to various reasons like the separatist militancy and the way whole thing was handled by authorities. The spiritual zest to worship the Goddess Ragnya Devi, to whom this temple is dedicated, was in the air. There was a big congregation of local Muslims who greeted the visiting pandits with cold drinks and Kheer (a dessert made of milk and rice). The Kashmir CM Farooq Abdullah and many other Kashmir Ministers also turned up for this emotional occasion marked by reunion with many a pandits.
The local Muslims and the ministers said that all concerned should work for return of Pandits to the valley, as Kashmiiryat is incomplete without the pandits, who are integral part of the Kashmir’s culture and life. Many a pandits also promised to work towards such a goal, to over come the divides created by the militant and political forces. The return of pandits to the valley has already begun, though it is a trickle at the moment.
Kashmir issue has been seen by the two neighbors, Pakistan and India, more as an issue of ‘real estate’ only. Kashmir has been treated as the territory which has to be won over by any means. The Government of Pakistan has regularly used ‘Kashmir’ issue to retain their hold on the political power in Kashmir, while in India, for far too long the central Government ignored the aspirations of the local population. In this whole scenario the real essence of Kashmir, Kashmiriyat got undermined and the issue started being presented as a communal one and as the site of dispute between two neighboring countries.
The soul of Kashmir’s culture has been a thick interaction between different religious traditions, teachings of Buddha, Vedanta, and Sufi tradition of Islam. Kashmir was the place where Buddhism spread far and wide and most of the population, except the upper caste embraced Buddhism. With attacks on Buddhism in 8th Century the tide turned. Later many Sufis came to Kashmir and preached their version of Islam. The most famous of them has been Nooruddin Noorani, popularly known as Nund Rishi. He was influenced by Lal Dedh, who herself was influenced by the earlier Sufis. Her mystical verses have a Shaivite form. Today both Hindus and Muslims regard her as their own. Like the great Bhakti saint, Kabir, there is a story that when she died her body turned into a heap of flowers, half of which were consigned to flames by Hindus, while the remaining half was buried by Muslims.
Nund Rishi wrote in appreciation of Lal Dedh, about her syncretic spiritual values which taught that one should not differentiate between a Hindu and a Muslim, one should realize one’s own self and that’s what God is. On Similar lines Nund Rishi focused on purification of soul. He bitterly criticized Mullahs and Brahmins whose focus is more on rituals than on spirituality and morality of the religions. Nund Rishi’s was a sort of mass movement in Kashmir, which affected many Kashmiris and they embraced Islam as taught by him.
Such a rich heritage has come under the threat from last three decades in particular. The vexed Kashmir issue got the communal slant due to the intrusion of Al Qaeda type elements, once their work of driving away Russian forces from Afghanistan was over. The Kashmiri militancy assumed different form during the decades of 1990s, it was communalized during this period. Amongst many factors contributing to worsening of Kashmir situation, one was the worsening communal scenario in India in the decade of 80’s which added fuel to the fire of terrorism in Kashmir. Meanwhile, a communal angle was being given to the harmony prevalent between Kashmiri pandits and the local Muslim population. Terrorists took advantage of that distortion.
Due to the local dissatisfaction of people, their feeling of alienation, the evil designs of the Pakistan Mullah-Military complex; totally backed by US imperialist goals, the militancy changed its tune and Kashmiri pandits started being targeted. The matters became worse off due to the policies of Jagmohan, who was Governor of the state. While the delegation of Kashmir people was preparing to call upon pandits to request them not to leave the valley, the state Governor provided them the transport to leave the valley. Most local leaders of Muslim community opposed the move of sending pandits away from Kashmir, but encouraged by Jagmohan, the Pandits left the valley. Essentially a problem between two neighboring countries assumed a communal color.
The condition of pandits, living in refugee camps has been quiet pitiable and barring few of them, most of them had to face immense suffering. Surely apart from pandits many a Kashmiri Muslims also had to leave the valley due to the twin attack from the terrorist groups and high handedness of the Indian military, which behaved more like and occupation army. Its heavy presence coupled with long years of stay in the valley totally distorted the civic life in Kashmir. The communal forces in India selectively harped on the plight of Kashmiri pandits while the other victims of Kashmir violence were totally left out of their scheme of propaganda. The tragedy is that while communal forces kept talking of the plight of pandits, during six years of BJP led NDA rule hardly anything different was done for the victims of militancy, and the lop sided policies of the leadership, dominated by the policies of central Government continued.
While some left over of militant’s actions and more of the imprint of army highhandedness are still visible, it seems with democratization process increasing, with local political leadership coming out to express the Kashmiri people’s aspirations, and partly also due to the change in the policies of US, peace seems to be slowly retuning to Kashmir. This Kheer Temple congregation is a signal of revival of the spirit of Kashmiriyat, the heart and souls of Kashmir. One hopes and wishes this spirit will strengthen in times to come, aspirations of people of Kashmir will be expressed and implemented through the democratically elected Governments of Kashmir and India-Pakistan are able to cultivate the friendly relations, which is the best guarantee for peace in the region.

By Ram Puniyani

Police arresting innocent citizens and activists under operation Greenhunt

Police in Chhatisgarh is arresting innocent citizens especially dalits and tribals, and activists under the operation Greenhunt by declaring them naxals. This was brought to light in the MP State level Convention of All India Secular Forum (AISF), held at Bhopal recently. In the forum the present situation of the country was discussed, “which is fraught with communalism, regionalism, naxalism, violence and gross violation of human rights. Even parallels were drawn in the instances of violence perpetuated in India against its minorities especially the women, to that carried out in Bosnia and Rwanda. Deliberations were carried out on the Communal Violence Bill as well.
Speaking on the occasion, Irfan Engineer spoke about discrimination faced by the Christians in Odisha and the people’s tribunal established there. He also talked of denial of citizenship rights to Muslims in Assam under the pretext that they can be Bangladeshi migrants.
Ram Puniyani explained the violation of human rights in the context of communalism where Muslims are targeted and labeled as terrorists. Likewise, the Christians are targeted because they are believed to be converting Hindus to Christianity. Imperialism and identity politics are marginalizing these groups further, he said.
Puniyani also cited the trend that communal violence consolidates the regime of communal parties in the state. The example of this is BJP. The BJP regime also saw saffronizaion of textbooks and education in a fascist manner.
Mr. Damle said that even today the police is not filing cases brought up by Dalits under the Atrocities act. Instead less severe charge under the IPC is filed to protect the perpetrators of violence against the dalits. He also highlighted the injustice carried out against the tribals and dalits in naxal affected areas where the state is trying to grab the land for mining.
Jayant Verma from Jabalpur condemned the action of the Chhatisgarh government which is making arbitrary arrests to persecute dalit and tribal activists as naxals. He also linked the operation Greenhunt to the politics of mining minerals.
Irfan Engineer informed the participants of the Sadbhavana Yatra that’s going to take place from Ayodhya to Wardha between 2nd to 11th October this year. He explained the rationale behind the yatra and asked for active participation.

Are we heading towards a failed democracy?

A child dies in the incubatory of a hospital due to the negligence of the staff. Parents run around for justice to all and sundry, yet to no avail. Finally, they placed the dead body of the child on a busy cross-road. The entire administration, including the media, came to take notice of the issue.
A woman is given talaq (divorce) by her husband. The role of two clerics is supposedly wrong, as per the woman. This woman approaches certain TV correspondent for assistance. The TV crew accompanied the woman to meet the clerics. But story is still not made until the women started beating the clerics with chappals.
A man runs from pillar to post seeking justice. Sole of his shoes come out but the concerned people do not come to listen to his problem. Finally, he collects the media, douses himself with kerosene and immolates himself. The story of injustice met out to him is aired on all the channels and the concerned officials promise action will be taken against the guilty.
Countless people sit at Jantar Mantar or designated places for protest in the capitals of all states but their protests fall on deaf ears. The moment a politician joins their cause and threatens a stir, certain public vehicles are burnt, few innocent people thrashed for no fault of their own, a police lathi-charge takes place, and their causes get highlighted.
Where is justice? Is justice only for those who take the law in their hand and know how to get their voice heard? Will a common man ever get justice in such a system?

Dual standards for justice won’t bring peace

Maoist guerillas allegedly removed the railway track leading to several civilian deaths. Several CRPF personals were killed in an ambush while an army petrol jeep was blown up to pieces. CRPF men are being attacked day and night in Maoist affected areas.
Yet we are talking of initiating discussions with the Maoists. No serious counter-offensive operation has been planned yet.
Cut to another scene! A young man goes missing from the village. After a long search, he is not found. People tell that he was picked up by the army. Army men themselves point out where his corpse could be located. People gather around his funeral to protest. Stone pelting started. Army started firing indiscriminately on protesting civilians, leading to deaths of more people, including a woman.
Justice is denied at both places. While in Maoists affected areas, no action against those who are killing the CRPF men is injustice to all those army men and general people who laid their lives to Maoist insurgency.
Injustice is also being done in the Kashmir Valley, when we are denying the basic right to protest for the Kashmiris and resultantly indulging in gross human right violations.
Lately, we ourselves have started treating Kashmir and its people as if they are foreign people. To some extent Kashmiris are themselves to be blamed for this because they kept a separate identity for themselves even during times of peace.
But why are we indulging in actions as if the poor Kashmiris belong to occupied territory. This is the kind of treatment that was done by erstwhile kings when they occupied other territory. Youth were killed, women were raped and the people in general kept under strict control. It is said right to protest is the basic fundamentals in a democracy. We are not even allowing the Kashmiris to protest.
We are talking of coming to discussions with the Maoists, we are talking of coming to discussions with the separatist elements in North East and we are talking of discussions with Pakistan on Kashmir. Never ever have we talked of discussions with leaders of our own Kashmiri people. Why?
Peace cannot return to either of the two places because of our flawed policies. Neither will the Maoists come to have carrot without a stick on the back. Nor will we be able to win the confidence of Kashmiris through unwarranted use of force. Particularly not, if we continue to treat the Kashmiris as ‘the other people’!
These discussions were carried out by the forum members consisting of prominent journalists in a meeting of JATI – Journalists in Action for Tomorrow’s India.

Caste Politics and Census

Rave reviews have been received over Life Watch’s exclusive article “Unconstitutionally Yours!” highlighting the non-inclusion of caste and religion columns from the ongoing exercise of Census 2011. This is to be remembered that the Government had agreed to include a OBC column in this year’s sensex after a gap of 79 years after high-pressure lobbying by OBC satraps and angry outbursts against the Government by three Yadavs, viz. Mulayam, Laloo and Sharad. Despite agreeing, half-hearted results have led to no results.
The fact that despite the Government agreeing and going ahead with the Census exercise, the pros and cons of including caste in the ongoing census exercise are still being debated in the Group of Ministers (GoM) meet reveal the inherent unwillingness to include it, whatever be the motive.
In one such meet held recently, a presentation was given by the office of the Registrar General of India on the pros and cons of including caste in the ongoing census exercise.
Both, RGI Chandramouli and PG Dhar Chakravarthy, gave a presentation to the GoM on the issue. Sources confirm that RGI officials made it clear that it was a difficult feat logistically to include caste in the Census and that this could be done only in the second phase of the exercise. Some members of the GoM even went back to the history to prove their point—that even the last caste-based census in 1931 was flawed. “In West Bengal alone 1,38,000 people had declared themselves to be casteless,” they said.
Significantly, law minister M. Veerappa Moily continues to remain a great supporter of including caste in the Census.
Unfortunately, behind the hue and cry raised over including caste in the Census, the other important issue raised by Life Watch (see June 1-15 issue) of removal of religion and mother tongue column, which used to be there in the census forms till last census, has been silently ignored.

FISSURES GETTING DEEPER IN BIHAR

Strange are the ways of politics. It is still sometime for the final countdown for assembly polls to begin in Bihar. But fissures between JD (U) and BJP are close to reaching a point of no return over Nitish’s strict denial to allow campaigning for Narendra Modi and Varun Gandhi in the State. Despite BJP spokesperson Shahnawaz Hussain’s categorical remarks of there being no Article 370 in Bihar, implying that democratically and constitutionally, it was not possible to stop a party leader from electioneering in any other state, the BJP was left with no choice but to become quiet when Nitish Kumar didn’t budge from his stand. BJP has decided to take into account JD(U)’s sensitivities when deciding the campaigners in the State. Obviously, ground has been conceded by the BJP which had to bow to Nitish’s requests without really saying so. After all, politics is politics and ultimately, compulsions prevailed.
However, things are not so rosy at ground level. Several cases of sloganeering and verbal attacking have taken place in recent past between JD(U) and BJP workers. These fissures may widen further as polls draw nearer and campaigning becomes more cut-throat. Both parties will have to keep a watch on its workers and prevent unwanted disturbance.
The two parties seemed on a splitsville course, when just a few days later, BJP reportedly said that JD(U)’s sensitivities will be taken into consideration when deciding the campaigners in the state. Obviously, ground had been conceded by the BJP. It had bowed to Nitish’s requests without really saying so. So, politics is politics and ultimately, compulsions prevail. The BJP-JD(U) is also likely to stick to their 2005 seat sharing formula, which has not come as a surprise. It can be left unsaid that the 15-year-old partnership cannot afford to break at this point, just months before Bihar polls.
The entire drama started when Bihar Chief Minister Nitish Kumar objected to a poster showing incorrect pictures of some Muslim school girls of Azamgarh (UP), presumably shown as from Gujarat. But what got him fuming was an advertisement in a local daily showing him and Modi holding hands at an earlier election campaign in Ludhiana. This immediately aroused in him fears of any potential loss of Muslim votes at this delicate juncture i.e just ahead of state elections. Nitish, then stretched it a bit too far by returning the Rs 5 crore Kosi flood relief money back to Gujarat and canceling a dinner he was to host for the BJP during its National Executive at Patna. Modi is despised by the state’s Muslim electorate post the Godhra riots. Since the campaigning would be for the alliance as a whole, therefore it is very likely to show Kumar as a Modi supporter and damage his image in front of the 12-16% Muslims of the state. Hence the vociferous stubbornness at not letting his state counterpart campaign in Bihar. Likewise, Varun Gandhi’s speeches are ridden with communal overtones, so Nitish cannot afford to be seen as friendly with him. When the Bihar Chief Minister sent a police team to Surat to inquire into published advertisements, it created cracks in the coalition. But his recall of the cops at BJP’s protest showed that the fissures were just temporary. Both the allies have known their indispensability to each other. And that is why Deputy Chief Minister Sushil Kumar Modi’s accompanying Nitish on the last leg of his Vishwas Yatra did not surprise. Nitish’s statement to the media on the same day, “Everything is fine”, has silenced any alarm bells.

Files do not move in Delhi as Didi prepares to knock-out Left from Bengal

Trinamool Chief Mamata Banerjee has tasted blood in Bengal. After battering the Left in West Bengal’s civic poll elections, the Railway Minister is preparing to deliver the knock-out punch in West Bengal, in the Assembly elections to be held next year. With eyes on Chief Minister’s seat, she has stationed herself in the State to consolidate the gains of the civic polls and get the momentum going till the elections.
Focus on Bengal has shifted the focus from Railways in Delhi so much so that the Ministry is acutely feeling the punch of Mamata’s aloofness from the Ministry. Inside sources within Railways reveal that the files are not moving at all. Transfers and postings are not taking place and even small day-to-day decisions are getting delayed. “If the Minister is not present, how can you expect others to take decisions? Neither can all the files be sent to Kolkata for her perusal,” said the source.
Due to her absence from the Ministry, several promises made during the budget still remain unmet. Not to mention the 375 stations that were to be made as Adarsh stations, even the New Delhi and Anand Vihar railway stations have not been developed as per expectations. With such a big infrastructure in place, Anand Vihar station has just a few trains moving from there. New Delhi railway station too has plethora of problems (see Life Watch, May 1-15, 2010).
Even though this issue was discussed within the Trinamool Congress, the outcome was that Mamata should retain the portfolio as there was no statutory requirement for her to stay in Delhi as railway minister. When quizzed, sources say that there may not be a statutory requirement but what about the moral requirement, with such huge amount of work pending in files lying on tables. The more hands-on minister is required at Railways immediately, feels people within the Ministry.The reshuffle in Manmohan Singh cabinet is due anytime now but is being postponed because Mamata’s final view whether she will retain the Ministry or will give it to someone else is not known yet. After all, given its emerging political status in West Bengal, the Congress is not likely to overrule her proposal.